I don't know if I was lucky or sheltered or oblivious, but I really don't remember much teasing going on around me as a kid. There was a boy who liked to make up stupid rhymes with people's names, which I found annoying but not particularly upsetting. A little Baptist girl once yelled at me on the playground that I was going to Hell and I remember being startled to realize she actually meant it. The only thing close to bullying I can remember was the one time I saw an older kid dumped into a trash can when I was a tiny little 5th grader touring Middle Schools.
Honestly, the worst emotional abuse I ever witnessed was dished out by my first grade teacher, who doted on her few teacher's pets and mercilessly berated pretty much everyone else. Oddly enough, it was me (teacher's pet because I was a shy, well-behaved child who made the teacher feel successful by arriving in her class already reading well-above grade level) who was made so miserable by the inequity of the situation that my parents eventually transferred me out of the class near the end of the year.
At any rate, I bring all this up because yesterday when I picked Mr. Pants up from preschool, we walked into the coat room to get his stuff and there was one of his friends (we'll call him Peter), standing in the middle of the floor looking at me desperately, tears running down his face. He was dressed to go outside, as were a bunch of other kids in the room. The other kids were chanting, Peter hat Loo-loo gemacht! and laughing and although that's not slang I know, I could tell from the puddle on the floor at the back of the room and the damp drawstring bag of clothes Peter was clutching what must have happened.
Somewhat horrified, I leaned down and talked to Peter, asking him what was wrong and telling him everything was fine (his clothes had already been changed), no big deal, everyone has accidents sometimes... gave him a hug when my words seemed to have no effect, spouted more reassuring words... finally got a nod out of him and possibly a reduction in sobs... was dimly aware of the teacher coming in with a mop... answered Mr. Pants's, Why is Peter crying? and encouraged him to give his friend a hug...
I think, although I was more than a little distracted, the kids stopped chanting when they noticed me taking notice of Peter. It could have been because the teacher came in, though, although she certainly didn't say anything to the tormentors and I was dismayed to hear her tersely tell Peter (in German, although his first language is English and I know she speaks English) to "Stop crying now," which I heard her impatiently repeat to him several times before we finally left the school. (By that point, Peter seemed much better but was still sniffling at the back of the line of kids waiting to go outside.)
The ride home, then, was a lengthy rambling discussion of "teasing"* and how it hurts people's feelings. What feelings does it hurt? Mr. Pants wanted to know, which flummoxed me briefly. It hurts your happy feeling and makes it a sad feeling, is what I ended up saying.
*(Mr. Pants has long had a fascination with The Bearenstain Bears and Too Much Teasing, which has perplexed me, since I'd never seen that kind of thing at his school before. It also irritates me, since the book plays into hill-billy stereotypes and ends with a within-socially-accepted-bounds revenge scenario. Not my favorite book. But he is from time to time obsessed with it. I decided it must be helping him work through something important, so I keep reading it whenever he asks.)
Having recently watched This Emotional Life* from PBS, which has a major section devoted to a truly tragic bullying story, I tried to impress upon Mr. Pants that I hoped if he saw a kid being teased he would stick up for them and say, "Stop doing that! That's mean!" to the teasers, just like Brother Bear (and not like Mr. Pants himself on some occasions, like last week when he proudly demonstrated how he and his friends had taunted, "NO MORE PETER!" over and over again to the poor boy because they didn't want to play with him).
*(Good show, but watch out - it's not real happy. It did say something over 90% of bullying situations stop if just one uninvolved kid makes clear they don't approve of the bullying. Impressive, eh? Remembering that had me kicking myself for not directly confronting the kids at school; it's hard to balance all these things in the heat of the moment, you know?)
And Mr. Pants wanted to know why people tease. Which, well, we all know why people tease, right? They tease people they secretly worry are better than them to make themselves feel better, and they tease people who are easy targets (having peed their pants or dressed or acted or looked different from the crowd) because... they think it's fun?
I don't think it's fun, said Mr. Pants.
Good answer! I tried rethinking/restating/re-something, and asked, Does that make sense?
No, said Mr. Pants, Teasing doesn't make sense.
Which it doesn't, does it? I realized teasing has always been explained to me in exactly that "it's how insecure people try to build themselves up" way, but with a bunch of four-year-olds? It seemed more primal.
Pondering that. And also this article I saw from the New York Times last week on the role bullying plays in the social hierarchy of high school. It's worth a read. Main fascinating take-away: it's actually kids near the top of the hierarchy who are the most frequent victims and perpetrators of bullying (the kids at the true pinnacle are rarely either, but probably didn't get to their position by being angelic altruists).
Thoughts?
Oh, and also pondering the somewhat-related latest kerfuffle in the mommy blogosphere - belittling comments left on this article about highly successful mommy bloggers, the cultural bigotry/misogyny that allows such comments to flourish discussed at length on Her Bad Mother, and a marvelous terse response to the whole shebang from Daring Fireball (I can't figure out how to link to a single post there, so if you can't find it, he basically just calls out the article's author for acting mystified as to why so many people regularly check in on Dooce when all Heather Armstrong writes about is mundane parenting stuff like laundry and vomit... to liberally rephrase, Daring Fireball says, Duh, it's because she's a great writer... subtext: mommies can be great writers and they can write greatly about mommyness).
Further thoughts?
***
And the title of this post is one of those inscrutable comments Mr. Pants is wont to throw out - in a most serious tone - during discussions like today's. And the picture is one of an 8-page story drawn and then dictated by Mr. Pants after the incident. His first story! More on that tomorrow, maybe.